How should authors respond to reviewer comments?

A response letter should address each reviewer comment, explain the action taken and identify where changes appear in the manuscript. Authors remain responsible for the scientific response and should explain any disagreement respectfully with evidence.

Use the submission-readiness checklist · Read our editorial policy

Our Journal Resubmission Support Process

01 Share Your Manuscript & Decision Letter

Send us your manuscript together with the journal decision letter, reviewer comments, editor feedback, and any revised files available.

02 Review Editorial & Reviewer Feedback

We review the editor's decision and reviewer comments to identify the revisions, clarifications, formatting changes, and supporting documents required.

03 Create a Revision Plan

The requested changes are organized into a clear revision plan so each reviewer or editor concern can be addressed systematically.

04 Revise & Strengthen the Manuscript

We support language editing, clarity, structure, consistency, journal formatting, and presentation based on the requested revisions while preserving the author's research and conclusions.

05 Prepare the Response to Reviewers

We help organize a clear point-by-point response explaining how reviewer comments were addressed and where corresponding changes appear in the revised manuscript.

06 Final Resubmission Readiness Check

Before resubmission, the revised manuscript, response letter, references, formatting, and required files can be checked against the target journal's current instructions.

Resubmission Support Options for Research Manuscripts

Choose support according to the journal decision, reviewer feedback, manuscript condition, and resubmission requirements.

Revision & Resubmission Support

For manuscripts receiving reviewer comments or a revise-and-resubmit decision.

  • Reviewer Comment Assessment
  • Academic Language Editing
  • Manuscript Revision Support
  • Journal Formatting Review
  • Reference & Citation Check
  • Response-to-Reviewers Support
  • Final Resubmission Readiness Check
DISCUSS YOUR REVISION

Rejected Manuscript Support

For authors preparing a rejected manuscript for submission to a more suitable journal.

  • Decision Letter Review
  • Reviewer Feedback Assessment
  • Manuscript Editing
  • Alternative Journal Selection Guidance
  • New Journal Formatting
  • Submission Document Review
  • Pre-submission Readiness Check
DISCUSS YOUR MANUSCRIPT

Turn Reviewer Feedback Into a Stronger Resubmission

A journal rejection or revision request does not necessarily end the publication process. Careful analysis of reviewer feedback, targeted manuscript revision, accurate formatting, and a clear response letter can help you prepare a stronger resubmission. Final editorial and publication decisions always remain with the journal.

We support researchers worldwide, including in the GCC and Türkiye.

Resubmit

with a clearer revision strategy

If your manuscript was rejected, we can also help you evaluate whether revision for the same journal or preparation for another suitable journal is more appropriate. Journal recommendations should be assessed against scope, article type, audience, author guidelines, fees, and current indexing information before submission.

Frequently Asked Questions About Journal Resubmission

Start by carefully reviewing the editor's decision letter and reviewer comments. Identify whether the manuscript needs scientific or methodological changes, clearer explanations, language editing, formatting corrections, or a different journal. A structured revision plan can then be prepared before resubmission.

Reviewer comments are normally answered point by point. Clearly state the change made for each comment and indicate where it appears in the revised manuscript. If you respectfully disagree with a suggestion, provide a clear academic explanation rather than ignoring the comment.

In many cases, yes, provided you follow the relevant journal and publisher policies. Before submitting elsewhere, use useful reviewer feedback to strengthen the manuscript and reformat it according to the new journal's current author guidelines. The new journal should also be checked for scope, suitability, and current indexing status.

Useful documents include the latest manuscript, editor decision letter, reviewer reports, previous submission files, tables and figures, supplementary materials, and the target journal's current author guidelines. For a revise-and-resubmit decision, include any response letter already prepared.

No. Resubmission support can help improve manuscript clarity, presentation, formatting, and responses to reviewer feedback, but acceptance, peer-review outcomes, publication timelines, and indexing decisions remain entirely with journal editors, reviewers, publishers, and indexing databases.

Yes. We support researchers, PhD scholars, and faculty members in Türkiye, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Oman, and other GCC countries with reviewer-response preparation and manuscript resubmission.

Researchers should verify the journal-indexing requirements recognised by their university, funder, employer, or evaluation framework before submission. Strong manuscript preparation can improve submission readiness, but it cannot guarantee acceptance or indexing.

What should you confirm before ordering manuscript support?

Which details are needed for a scope-based quote?

Provide the subject area, article type, word count, target journal if known, requested service and deadline. Confirm the deliverables and exclusions in writing before work begins.

Who makes the final publication and indexing decisions?

Journal editors decide acceptance under their journal’s policies. Indexing organizations determine journal coverage; manuscript-support fees do not buy acceptance or indexing.

Where should authors verify journal requirements?

Use the target journal’s official author instructions for manuscript requirements. Check Web of Science journal coverage in Clarivate’s Master Journal List and consult COPE for publication-ethics resources.

Service information: ISI Journal Indexing · Content updated . External journal policies may change.

Request a manuscript-support quote

Send your subject area, article type, word count, target journal if known, and deadline. Agree the scope, deliverables and timing before work begins.

WhatsApp: +44 7414 636758   Email: info@isijournalindexing.com

Submission checklist · Editorial policy and corrections · Researcher questions